Lean Manufacturing in a NON Widget World
Thursday, April 20th, 2006If you work for a company that does any fabrication and has more than one hundred employees, then you have most surely heard of lean manufacturing.
I won’t give a full explanation for the unschooled, but here is a short description of lean manufacturing:
-
The main feature is the goal to eliminate all waste of any kind from every aspect of the business:
- customer relations
- product design
- supplier network
- factory management
-
The principles applied in a lean enterprise can be stated simply:
- Zero waiting time
- Zero Inventory
- Scheduling — internal customer pull instead of push system
- Batch to Flow — cut batch sizes
- Line Balancing
- Cut actual process times.
Once you have your employees on board and understanding lean principles, there are very few enemies left to overcome in a working lean manufacturing environment.
I have discovered two major enemies in our business to lean manufacturing.
We have some lines in our product stream that are very friendly to lean principles. They have very similar, repetitive assembly and processing functions.
One difficult fabrication area has two real problems.
1) Extreme Variation.
2) Short Runs.
Extreme variation is a problem in lean manufacturing because it is perhaps the anti-type to lean manufacturing principles. A well functioning lean product stream attempts to remove all variation. When this is impossible, the next step is to standardize the processing of the variation–effectively minimizing the negative impact of any variation that is inherent in the product. The variation in this fabrication area isn’t bad variation. I’m talking about the difference in one part from another, not poor designs or bad components.
This leads to the second problem, though part of the first problem. Our average production run in this problem area is less than ten units per run. We started trying to look for similar products on different work orders in an attempt to reduce the variation–treating them like a single run. We had very little success with this. Why?
1) Huge Product Line.
2) Extremely Short Lead Time.
The huge product offering keeps similar products separated more often than not.
The short lead time keeps us from being able to schedule similar products together. The first work order usually can’t wait for the similar product on another work order. One day turn around for custom built units happens every day.
We will not abandon continuing to make this better. In fact, we are far from exhausting this effort.
I think the next step for us in lean manufacturing for this problem area will be a heavy effort aimed at treating the processing of small runs like the product itself.
In other words, short runs have a bulk of the percentage of effort into getting them out the door wrapped up in their processing. A gain in cleaning up the processing is as good as a gain in fabrication in the net result.
Combined with this, I want to get standardized work and work stations established to the max in this area. We have had a very busy season that kept us from fully implementing all that we want.
Also, we still have a lot of material movement to streamline.
Lean Manufacturing is the only way to go. It is, however, quite challenging in some situations.
It will be interesting to see the hybrid approach these problems fashion over the next few years.
Maybe I’ll write the new version of lean manufacturing for the anti-widget industry someday.
Regards.







